For several months now I’ve been reading Leadership in the Wilderness by Dr. Erica Brown.
During that whole time I’ve been going back and forth in my mind about whether or not to write a review.
I decided some time ago to only write reviews of books that I recommend you buy and read.
That’s been my trouble with this book. There are aspects of it that I can definitely recommend. But, there’s another side of it that I’m not enjoying at all.
There’s no doubt in my mind that the right leader at the right time can inspire his followers and cause them to excel.
The opposite is also true. A weak leader can cause an otherwise strong group of people to perform significantly below their abilities.
Almost every group needs a leader. This is true of small groups and becomes even more necessary for large groups.
Being a leader of a nation is not an easy task.
Dr. Brown explores the leadership tests that Moshe Rabbeinu faced in the wilderness.
It seems that they never ended. From the moment he first spoke to the Jewish people enslaved in Egypt until the end of Sefer Bamidbar there is one crisis after another.
Erica Brown seeks to peek beneath the surface of the Biblical narrative and understand Moshe as a person.
With every crisis Dr. Brown tries to answer some fundamental questions:
- Why did Moshe act in a particular way?
- Was his reaction appropriate?
- What can we learn about leadership from this event?
These are important questions. I believe that Dr. Brown’s approach can teach every reader important principles of leadership.
Approaching the Torah Text
I do have some issues with Dr. Brown’s use of the Torah text and her commentary on it.
In her book I’ve found several instances where her commentary grates on me.
Let me share just one with you, some of her commentary on the story of the meraglim – the spies.
We read in Bamidbar Chapter 13:
2. Send for yourself men and they should spy out the land of Canaan that I am giving to the children of Israel …
Thirty eight years later, toward the end of his life, Moshe recounts this incident to the people who will be entering the Land:
22 And all of you gathered to me and you said, “Let us send men before us and they will spy out the land for us …”
The problem between these two passages is clear. Did Moshe send the spies because God commanded it or because the people demanded it?
Dr. Brown takes this approach (page 118):
Virtually all of history has its accompanying revision, and this passage is no exception.
Personally, I prefer the approach suggested by Rabbi Dessler. You can find it in Hebrew in Michtav MiEliyahu (Vol 1, page 189) or in Strive for Truth (Vol 2, page 267-8):
According to R. Dessler the passages in Bamidbar and Devarim contain different details about the event. We need both passages to get the full picture.
Here’s what happened:
- First the people asked for spies to be sent (Devarim 1).
- Then Moshe asked God what to do (not explicitly recorded in the text).
- Finally, God told Moshe to do what he thought was best (Bamidbar 13). That’s why the passage begins with “God spoke to Moshe.”
Limits of Interpretation
On the other hand, Dr. Brown seems to be saying that Moshe lied to the people in Devarim and God let the lie stand and be included in the Torah!
Now, let’s be clear. I have no problem with someone suggesting a new interpretation of the Torah.
We see it all the time. Rashbam disagrees with Rashi. Ramban at times argues strongly against Rashi and Ibn Ezra.
I am, however, bothered by an interpretation that seems to me to raise a new difficulty in the text.
I think Leadership in the Wilderness is appropriate for those who are interested in the challenges and pitfalls of leadership.
Also, readers who appreciate Dr. Brown’s approach to understanding the Torah will enjoy this book.
Even those readers, like myself, who disagree with her Torah commentary, can still find value in her book.
I’ve said it before and I’ll keep saying it. A book like this must have an index!
At the very least there should be an index of Torah and talmudic sources that are quoted.
I’ve told people before that between one third and one half of the Jewish books that are sent to me for review should never have been published.
Though I disagree with much of Dr. Brown’s Torah commentary, I think her insights into leadership are very worthwhile.
Leadership in the Wilderness. Published by Maggid Books. 241 pages.
Disclosure: I was given a review copy of Leadership in the Wilderness by the publisher.
Your purchase of
Leadership in the Wilderness
from Amazon using this link provides financial support to Thinking Torah.